Alter Ego (1986) is a life sim for the Commodore 64. From the womb to this very moment, did our personal decisions make us who we are today? What if we got the chance to do it again? Would we choose differently?...

The cover art doesn't do the game justice. The face portraits are oddly limited. If we are going to use a Brady Bunch square to distill all human identities into 9 archetypes, wouldn't there be a lot more variety? Not much gradient here. The punk guy and wacky guy are too similar, there seems to be no stay-at-home Mom, and the morality seems to be pretty milquetoast. Are the punk guy and frizzy-haired woman supposed to represent evil? Why not put the actual title of the game in the middle? But since this game is a fascinating premise, I will check the back cover for the first time.

Ok! Now I see what the game is going for. I like this. I want to see my alter ego life unfold from the very beginning. Stats will be more meaningful as they will be a direct reflection of my decisions, rather than a chance to minmax. Now that I consider it, minmaxing would be pretty dangerous in real life! Imagine having a person with zero strength or zero intelligence or zero dexterity. Well, Charisma is usually the dump stat, but we couldn't get (or keep) a job without it...
Status: Played it
What works 👍:
- [REPLAYABILITY] Endless replayability. That is a big deal for any game and the gold standard for a simulation game. Well done!
What didn't work 👎:
- [MUSIC] The game has no music.
- [SOUND] The game has no sound.
- [GRAPHICS] The game scarcely has any graphics. Please note that I LOVE text adventures (especially many of the classic Infocom games), so I don't need music or sound or graphics to enjoy a game. But it is only ok to forgo those things when the story and gameplay shine. And in this case...
- [STORY] This is the biggest problem with Alter Ego. Most of the vignettes are boring. I was astonished at how little effort was put into each scenario. The creator of the game seems to not realize that this is indeed a game. That means it should be interesting! Each scenario was a setup that was about as exciting as "go to the store". Or the setup was interesting, but the result would be "go to the store". Imagine the dullest visual novel in history. I personally study on a daily basis. Some of my textbooks are easily more interesting than many of the Alter Ego scenarios.
- [GAMEPLAY] This is tied to the story. If the life events were interesting, then it would be satisfying gameplay. If my social, intellectual, emotional, physical, etc stats were constantly on the screen and I could see them go up and down, there would be a sense of progression. If I could see my age grow up as I moved through the game, it would feel alive. But the events are dry, all my character's stats are on a different screen, and the stats barely change after individual events. Alter Ego doesn't give off "game". It gives off Duane Reade questionnaire.
Rating: 1.5 out of 4 Life Experiences


No comments:
Post a Comment